Little Knowledge is a Dangerous Thing.
Reading Julia’s post about Patrick’s parent-teacher conference (he failed Scissors, poor moppet) and whether to send him to Montessori made me ponder my own early scholastic experiences.
First of all, I would like to say that I, too, failed something. It will come as no surprise to my creditors, my mother, or the smug ATM machine I frequent that the pre-school subject I failed was Money. Specifically, nickels and dimes. I still maintain that as nickels are bigger, they are patently worth more than are dimes. What child-hating absurdist created our system of coinage, anyway?
But I digress.
The point of this entry (believe it or not) was that I am a big advocate of non-traditional public schools, especially for the early years. I went to an Open School for kindergarten and first grade. It was a public school with lots of gifted and talented programs and unusual curricula. In first grade I learned all of the usual things, but also took Spanish, sewing, and a literature class that focused on death–we read A Taste of Blackberries (boy stung to death by bees) and 1000 Paper Cranes (dying girl loves origami). Okay, that makes it sound strange, and yes, that unit precipitated an unattractive 6-year-old existential crisis (I want a fudgsicle and a copy of The Sickness Unto Death!) but it was great, really.
I also took workshops that year in carpentry and soap- and candle-making. I was on the literary magazine and in the “International Club”—the sole legacy of which is my ability to sing “Are You Sleeping?” in French, Sign Language, and Yiddish.
There were aspects of the school that were a little…much—we used to sit in a circle with linked arms, swaying and singing “We Shall Overcome,” and our school song was “Lean on Me,” by Bill Withers, but I suspect that was a product of the times.
It was during my years at that school that I developed a love of learning and an ability to integrate that learning into life outside the classroom that served me well when I was thrust into a mainstream public school system, where I remained through high school, where some of the classmates with whom I graduated could barely read, where I saw my first gun, and where I was so horrifically, stultifyingly bored that I stopped attending class regularly after the 7th grade.
Wherever your offspring fall on the abilities spectrum, Open Schools and similar institutions do a tremendous job, in my opinion, of accommodating individual interests and learning styles, and in translating them into achievement and confidence.
Besides, Open School hot lunches kick Regular School hot lunches’ ass.
Edited to add: We did have to do ALL of the basics–reading, writing, ‘rithmatic, etc. The electives were just gravy. There were a lot of interdisciplinary approaches, too. No one could, say, concentrate on spelling and opt out of long division.
Unrelated, but noteworthy:
Has anyone read this? I am curious, because I had heard some complimentary things about Letrazole–not in general, but in comparison to Clomid, especially for PCOS. What confuses me about the article is that it says Letrazole has been shown to cause problems when taken during pregnancy. Now, correct me if I am mistaken, but Letrazole (Femara), like Clomid, is taken for 5ish days in the first half of your cycle—it would be long gone by the time a pregnancy occurred, non? And–again, correct me if I’m wrong–most fertility drugs/hormones are contraindicated during pregnancy, non? So why the “Tsk, tsk, this is what you barren sluts get for using an off-label fertility treatment” routine? Am I missing something?
Oh! Back to the early scholastic reminisces portion of the entry:
I learned a passel of new words during my time at the Open School. Two of those words were “Infanta” (from the aforementioned Spanish class) and “Matricide”—leading to my belief (held through the 4th grade) that the term “Infanticide” referred to the assassination or murder of the daughter of the King of Spain.


10 Comments
Oh Alexa, you’re so smart.
My husband went to one of those new-fangled open schools for a few years in elementary school, at which point he got 2 years ahead of everyone else in math and behind in everyone else. I’m sure they’re great for students who can properly structure their time, but Hal? Not so much at the age of 10.
Soap-making? At the age of 6? Highly impressive.
That article is so obnoxious! Did they ever think that the people taking it are those TRYING to become pregnant, not those that already ARE? (”Now that you’re pregnant, here’s this handy-dandy fertility pill! Enjoy!”)
They already have very similar warnings against taking Clomid while pregnant, which is why my clinic demanded a blood pregnancy test before each cycle of Clomid. Sheesh.
As for the infanticide–oops! A little knowledge can be very dangerous!
That vocabulary story is hilarious.
I agree that the instruction in many public schools is deadly - it kills kids’ desire to learn.
I love the sound of your school. In the UK most private schools are (i) v expensive and (ii) very academic-focused. So not so much with the sewing and the candle making. I would have had a ball at your school.
What did you do when you weren’t at school from 7th grade on?
On the schooling issue - thank you for saying so well what I tried to say in my comment on Julia’s post. I had a very similar experience moving from Montessori to a string of bad (mostly Southern) public schools. I would never send my kids to a wacky school past about age 7 or 8, but before then, I think they’re great. You still have to figure out what works for an individual kid, but if you can afford to do it, I really do think Montessori or open schools or whatever (though Waldorf scares me a little) are great for really young kids.
And about the femara - sometimes, women take femara or clomid without realizing they’re already pregnant. It’s why good doctors require at least a home pregnancy test before starting it, some require a blood test. But still, it happens. That said, the two REs I spoke to when we were in the market both said they refused to prescribe femara because it isn’t an approved use. Dr. Drawl says he doesn’t believe there’s really much difference between clomid and femara.
I read the article before I read your comments on it, and I too was confused. As someone who has taken Letrozole for IUI 4 and IVF 1, I was a bit concerned by the headline, then baffled when reading the rest of the article.
I already mentioned in a previous comment that Clomid thinned my uterine lining far too much, hence WHYBAML thinking that Letrozole was the better way to go. Oh, who knows…these things switch around from being good for you to bad for you so quickly.
I wrote a post about that Femara article yesterday, then, of course, didn’t post it. But yes, what you said. Pregnant women should be cautious when taking fertility drugs. Got it, you all?
I went to an Open School for all of elementary school, then completely hated junior high, (Does ANYONE like jr. high? Worst schooling time of my life.) then went to an artsy fartsy high school full of all the misfits that wouldn’t fit in other places.
Name a non-legend drug, or for that matter a legend drug, that ISN’T contraindicated during pregnancy??? Printing something like that is like saying, “Water will make you wet…if you spill it on you!”
Duuuhhh!
My early school experience was so not-nurturing that they skipped me directly to first at age 5 (I could already read or something stupid). Spent the next 17 years emotionally, physically and (more or less) academically behind my classmates. No Kindergarten! Doesn’t that suck? One day they’ll get the early childhood thing right. If I ever produce offspring and if the process hasn’t drained all my resources, I’m totally going Montessori.
It really doesn’t take all that long to become acquainted with the basic outline of an IUI or an IVF cycle. It’s amazing to me how reporters can consistently mangle things. We are not high school journalists, are we?
Something else occurred to me about Femara/Letrozole–one of the reasons WHYBAML prescribed it is because it does not stay in the system very long. At most, its half-life is about 45 hours I think. As such, it doesn’t affect the uterine lining and cervical mucus like Clomid does.
There, everything you ever wanted to know about Letrozole/Femara and didn’t care enough to ask.