You Might Want To Skip This One.
On Saturday I had breakfast with my toothless, cancerous, manic depressive, math-obsessed father.
As previously noted, I hadn’t seen him in a while. Perhaps it is for this reason that I was rather rusty at the game I play when I do: Manic, Drunk, or Just Dad.
“Manic, Drunk, or Just Dad?” is the question I use to analyze my interactions with my father—I am an expert at said analysis, having been doing it for upwards of fifteen years now.
Some characteristics of “Manic” include:
1. Talking about possible ambitious life-plans such as starting one’s own traveling science museum
2. Rapidly detailing the benefits of recent odd purchases, which he just happens to have brought with him (tiny tripods, two-dozen plaster hands, or similar)
3. Presenting me with lavish and unasked for gifts
Some characteristics of “Drunk” include:
1. Reminding me that I am the only one he can talk to, as Wife #3 is not smart enough to understand him
2. Crying
3. Belligerent manipulation masquerading as affection
4. Once, when I was ten, harassing a band at a sporting event by repeatedly requesting Inagaddadavida.
But here is where it gets tricky. My father is…hmmm. Colorful? Eccentric? Would it help if I told you that he invented a shape?
A tetrahedrally space-filling toroid, to be more precise.
Anyhow, the third option, “Just Dad,” exists because almost any behavior that could be attributed to either “Manic” or “Drunk” has also been observed when my father was both sober and mood-regulated. Except the Inagaddadavida incident.
For instance, Saturday’s breakfast included both of the first two items I listed in the “Drunk” category (they so often go together), and in addition, my father drank throughout from a plastic bottle of “Seven-Up” he carried in his coat pocket. So—Drunk, right?
However! My father had all of his teeth pulled last year for radiation due to neck cancer, and is unable to swallow food without copious liquids—the ostensible reason for the bottle of clear soda. Also, he was not slurring his words, nor was he excessively calling me “kiddo.”
And besides, he displayed many “Manic” characteristics—the long, spooling loops of chatter, the entreating me to listen to a passage from a John Prine album, the insistence that those lyrics connect to a notebook connects to a concert connects to a cigarette case.
In the end, I was unable to make a determination. I spent the morning looking for clues and willing myself not to grab his Seven-Up bottle and swig from it—as a test, of course. Well, mostly. My first thought after dropping my father at his door was that I needed a drink. I went home, ate some leftover steak, and had a glass of wine at noon.
And then the guilt began.
You see, I wasn’t very nice to him. I got impatient with his rambling and annoyed when he started to cry. What sort of daughter am I, anyway? Normally I am able to be tolerant, funny, and kind. Normally I am able to listen patiently. But Saturday his prattle made me furious and I barely attempted to look interested. I sighed, I tossed my hair, I reminded him snottily that Brevity Is The Soul Of Wit. And then I felt bad and said something nice, and he started talking again, and the longer he talked the angrier I got. I was angry at him for making me sad and anxious on his behalf, I was angry at having served as his psychiatrist throughout my teen years, I was angry that my mother and brother share none of this burden with me, having simply cut him out of their lives years ago. I was angry at him for looking so frail, and I was angry at him for being simultaneously at my mercy and able to have shaped my fear of the world. I was angry that I was still playing “Manic, Drunk, or Just Dad” and will probably play it every time I see my father until he dies. Mostly I was angry because I had spent the previous weekend with the Nearly’s family, and spending time with the Nearly’s father only serves to underscore all the things my own father was not, and then all the good things I would have missed if he had been, if that makes sense.
After all, without my father, I might not be the person I am now. I might not have spent my first seven years aglow with the knowledge that to him, I was the cleverest, most amusing, wisest child on the globe. At the very least, my knowledge of polyhedra would be significantly less impressive.
And so now there is the guilt. I don’t know how much of this is actually guilt and how much is a selfish worry that my father will be despondent because of my cruelty and commit suicide as he has always threatened–and that it will be my fault if he does. I make it my job to be jokey and en garde, so as not to be caught unawares as I was at eleven, the first time he begged me to give him a reason not to kill himself.
Maybe I feel guilty only because it is too exhausting to figure out where the blame should lie, and it is easier to simply heap it upon myself.
Or, perhaps I feel guilty because I have become the kind of daughter who rolls her eyes when her father begins to weep into his bagel–cut with a pocketknife, the better to force down his cancer-ravaged throat–prompting him to wipe at his eyes and say “I’m sorry, I’m sorry,” over and over again, until I hand him a napkin.


15 Comments
Oh Alexa. Do not feel guilty or blame yourself for anything. You have got your hands full here. Be glad that you can see the good in him and leave it at that.
Alexa,
I wish I had soothing words that could act as a salve, healing your pain. Unfortunately I don’t - struggling with the relationships with my parents has never been a strong point for me.
In short, you are in my thoughts. I’m sorry this is so gut-wrenchingly difficult.
I wish we could all have the Cleaver family, but I’m afraid it doesn’t exist. The blame does not fall on you, or on him.
It is - what it is. It sucks, but it still is.
Thinking of you…
How could we skip over something that obviously weighs down your heart? When that awful time comes that we begin to parent our parents, especially when it’s as early as your pre-teens, how can you not feel burdened? You know that you shouldn’t bear the brunt of your father’s “idiosyncasies”, but it still doesn’t make it easier to to ignore them, does it.
You’re guilty of being a good daughter. Don’t be so hard on yourself. YOU are still in the picture for him. That meaningful - despite the manic, drunk or just dad episodes.
Love your writing, by the way.
You cannot blame yourself for a thing, as hard as that is to realize. Your poor father is unfortunately at the mercy of his diseases — both his cancer and his mental illness. I can’t imagine how tough that is to watch, but you are doing your best with what you’ve been given. You need only be a dauughter, not a saint.
Hope things improve, dear.
That was really beautiful, sad, raw, painful, and honest, Alexa. I’m in awe of this post. And I can relate to this one particularly well.
Oh Alexa, the guilt is so tough, no matter how much you try to shed it, it’s still there. And comparing to a normal family! Oh my - that’s just, well, you just can’t do that I’m afraid. I get pretty sad sometimes when I hear about my bf’s father and all he does and is for my bf. Acceptance is one thing, constantly living in our own reality is another.
I hope you’re okay.
The guilt and responsibility you feel is such a heavy burden for anybody to carry, and when you are carrying it alone…it’s almost too much to bear. I cannot presume to understand your father or your relationship with him, but I have felt a similar burden many times in the past, and my heart goes out to you.
this is my first visit, and so they first post of yours i read. your situation sounds just awful, but lord can you write amazingly….
thank you. and i’ll be back..
What an amazing entry… gorgeous and heartbreaking and so damned evocative. Reminded me very much of a short story from the “Zoetrope: All-Story” book called, I believe, “Notes For My Biographer” (funny, sad and written from the perspective of a manic-depressive inventor).
omydearlord…
Alexa… wow… I’m just in shock at what you have had to endure in your relationship with your father. My heart is absolutely going out to you right now even though that might not be what you want to hear right now…
And as I read your words… your reactions to the ‘antics’ of your poor beleaguered father… so much of your emotion is so incredibly familiar to my own with respect to my ‘colourful’ mother.
After reading this… what comes to mind is something a wonderful therapist kept trying to drill into my brain. Something I heard, but didn’t believe for a very long time… and something that I think you will also struggle to absorb although you may hear it in your head… children do not owe their parents. It is a parent’s responsibility to make their child feel safe, secure, and cherished. It is not the children’s responsibility to take on that role for their parents…
It’s been a long time since I’ve seen that basic truth flouted so flagrantly by a parent… and I’m so sad that I’m seeing it in your post today.
Thinking of you.
I’m at a loss for words. I can’t imagine what you’ve been through.
Can I just tell you that you are dealing with this remarkably well? A parent with bipolar disorder and comorbidity is one of the most difficult things I can imagine.
Dealing with a loved one with bipolar is hard enough, but a parent? Please don’t be so hard on yourself. You are doing the best that you can and more than anyone else in your family has.
Take care of yourself first and be gentle. I think you are remarkably well adjusted and aware of how this situation affects you, what you can do to help and what is a waste of time and what is enabling, considering the situation.
I’m so sorry. I have sone experience trying to navigate bipolar as it relates to a loved one. If you ever need to vent, please consider me there for you.
I’m mean to my dad and he doesn’t give me nearly as much cause as yours. It sounds like you have a very human, and a mostly very humane, approach to this relationship. And it’s marvellous that you’ve persevered with it where others would not/have not.
I’m a new reader and wanted to say that this was beautifully written. I used to play the same game with my Dad, wondering if he’d be on or off the booze (and therefore sober or drunk driving), on or off the smoking, mad or glad to see me, overly chatty or absolutely silent and morose…. It’s absolutely no fun, is it? Especially when I, like you, was the only one who gave him time anymore. My Dad had mouth cancer, too, and even that didn’t stop him abusing his body. It’s taken me a while to realise that I don’t have to feel guilty at his problems and that I did help him in some small way. I hope you can realise the same.