She Who is Inappropriately Named.

by Alexa on October 22, 2008

Simone can’t hear.

I thought maybe typing that right at the beginning, getting it out of the way, would make this easier to write about, but guess what? No.

Yesterday was Simone’s big five-month developmental assessment at the NICU follow-up clinic. The appointment consists of visits with a neonatologist and nurse practitioner; a check-up; and a standardized test called the Bayley, administered by an occupational therapist. I might as well admit that I was feeling confident, going in. I knew Simone might have trouble with her fine motor skills, and maybe sitting, but I was wasn’t expecting anything but praise for how fine and fat she is growing, and what a strong, smart baby she has become. She is seen only once a month by Early Intervention, because after her evaluation in early September they decided she was doing too well to require more frequent visits. Though front-to-back still eludes her, she has started rolling back-to-front. Besides, each baby develops at her own pace: insert story about a friend-of-a-friend who didn’t talk until the eighth grade and is now a Rhodes Scholar, reminder that every child is a unique snowflake, et cetera, et cetera.

The evaluation started well. Simone is slightly above her adjusted age for cognitive skills, and a whole month above for expressive language. Her motor skills need some work, partly because I didn’t know she was supposed to be sitting at a tabletop to play with things (What does a baby need with a tabletop? A place to write? To hold tiny mock U.N. debates?), but her delay is relatively minor and not due to any physical limitation—she just needs practice.
I’m not sure exactly when it happened, but at some point the therapist began to look concerned. She asked whether Simone responds to her name. No, she doesn’t. Other words? Well…no. Does she turn toward noise? I hadn’t noticed, excellent and observant parent that I am.

Then, standing behind Simone, the therapist rang a metal handbell—LOUDLY. Loudly enough that my own ears were ringing. And Simone didn’t so much as flinch.

It was chilling, to watch Simone burbling obliviously in my face, while behind her gongs sounded and noisemakers shrilled. We tried rattles, crumpled paper, sudden clapping—nothing. I felt sick and panicked and unspeakably sad for my baby. And, I confess, weak with guilt. How did I miss this? How do you miss the fact that your baby can’t hear? Simone is very responsive to me, but it has now been demonstrated that she is responding to my facial expressions. She gets excited when Scott comes home from work, but not until she sees him. Her visual perception of her environment, it was noted, is especially keen, probably compensating for the fact that SHE CAN’T HEAR A DAMN THING.
After the Miracle Worker routine of bells and whistles and desperate cries of Helen!, the specialists conferred and then filed back in, looking grim. Because of what seems to be a hearing loss, Simone’s receptive language is at a two-month level. Examination of Simone’s ears reveals no wax or obvious fluid. She hasn’t had a fever or infection. She passed her newborn hearing exam, and because she learned a few months ago to mimic the intonation of “hello” (which, come to think of it, she hasn’t done in a long time), I am wondering whether she may have been able to hear at one point and now cannot. The neonatologist pulled some strings to get us a November 5th appointment with an ENT. November 5th seems terribly far away.

The best-case scenario, and the one I am fervently hoping for, is that there is fluid somewhere deep in Simone’s ears, and that all she will need is tubes put in to keep it draining and then therapy to make up the language acquisition skills lost by the months of deafness. The worst-case scenario is permanent, profound hearing loss. It can have a delayed onset, which I didn’t know, and Simone has several of the risk factors.
Believe me, I’m aware that as worst-case scenarios go this is a relatively cushy one; there are other, more devastating disabilities. But allow me to wallow for a moment. Simone has had PDA ligation surgery, multiple transfusions, severe jaundice, an infection, two bouts of acute renal failure, Retinopathy of prematurity, a small IVH, an aortic clot, osteopenia resulting in broken ribs, severe Bronchopulmonary dysplasia…the list goes on. She was doing so well, finally. And yet here we are, back in this place again.

This morning I was standing in the kitchen staring out the window when I remembered that the name Simone means “She who hears.”
You have to laugh, really. Well, I do, anyway, and I did, standing there with a bottle of formula in my hand. A possibly deaf baby named Simone. If I believed in god, I would think this was a slightly cruel divine joke. If my life were a short story I was editing, I would say this was a heavy-handed stylistic device and recommend the author stop trying to be so clever.

You have to laugh. People say that all the time, but I really do believe it. I think it is probably as close to a life’s philosophy as I get. Anyway, nothing is really any different than it was yesterday. I still love my Simone to distraction, she still needs to be fed and changed and nibbled on. We won’t know any more until her ENT appointment, and if the news is going to be bad, nothing we can do will stop it from coming. It’s business as usual around here. Except, I suppose, that we can now swear in front of the baby with impunity. I guess it’s true what they say about silver linings.
Standing

Leave a Comment

{ 267 comments… read them below or add one }

tash October 23, 2008 at 6:43 am

My eyes are just brimmed with tears, I’m just so sorry, Alexa. Please go easy on you. Because Simone? Looks and behaves positively wonderfully, stillness through bell-ringing aside. You’ve given her everything she needs, and will continue to, and that is all anyone can ask. Holding you all in my heart.

Reply

Slim October 23, 2008 at 6:57 am

“how fine and fat she is growing, and what a strong, smart baby she has become”

Well, that’s all I can see, so I don’t blame you for not noticing that her hearing had changed. I’m sorry you’ve hit another bump.
I predict she’ll remain Baby of the Week for a good long time, however. That isn’t judged on hearing.

Reply

Me? A Mom? October 23, 2008 at 7:14 am

It’s not fair. That’s all I can keep saying to myself. And as a mother, my heart aches for you. But you are strong. So very strong. And I know you and Simone can tackle this. It sounds empty in the shadow of this, but I’ll be keeping you all in my thoughts.

Reply

Lee Anne October 23, 2008 at 7:21 am

I’m so sorry to hear this. Thoughts are with you and Simone for Nov. 5.

Reply

Patti B October 23, 2008 at 7:34 am

Sincerely sorry for the pain you & Scott are feeling, and hoping desperately for the best case scenario for Simone. And offering sidecars all around.

Reply

Maren October 23, 2008 at 7:43 am

:hugs: I wish good things for the follow up ENT appointment. I’m thinking of you. I’m also thinking about my cousin, who is hard of hearing. (He was born prematurely and both he and his twin had a brain hemorrhage; his twin didn’t make it. He is hard of hearing and quite learning disabled, but a curious fellow who loves baseball and girls. He went to a wonderful school in Massachusetts and learned how to lip read and he wears hearing aids and can talk incredibly well.)

Reply

A. W. October 23, 2008 at 7:44 am

To borrow from many others…that sucks. Hopefully the follow up goes well…if not, time to learn a new means of communication.

Reply

zenoma October 23, 2008 at 7:47 am

I’m so, so sorry for the sick worry and saddness you are feeling. But please, don’t feel guilty. (Yes, I know it’s impossible not to.) You are a phenomenal mother and Simone is so lucky to have you.

You already know that things could be much much worse so…in the mean time, know that many people are thinking about you and Simone and sending warm “well” wishes your way.

And by the way, those jammies are so damn cute! It makes me want to have a nibble of her myself!

Reply

amanda October 23, 2008 at 7:49 am

i don’t know what to say. i’m so, so, sorry, but also know absolutely that even if the worst case scenario is true, Simone is going to be better than fine. she will be fantastic. she will succeed. she will be loved and love in return. she deserves none of this, but if it given to her and to you, you guys will make it. your family is made of some of the strongest and best people i’ve ever come into contact with.

i’m sorry.

Reply

meghan October 23, 2008 at 7:51 am

I’m mostly a lurker…just wanted to say sorry you and Simone haven’t been able to catch a break and I’ll be hoping for the best case scenario on the 5th

Reply

elizasmom October 23, 2008 at 7:52 am

Would you like an inspirational story about one of my favorite karate students, who couldn’t hear, oh, any of the commands I ever gave, and kicked ass (literally, in this case) better than most of the other kids in class with him? Because I can do that.

In the meantime, I am sorry for this new development and hoping for a best-case scenario, and above all the strength to deal with whatever complications this adds to your and wonderful Simone’s life.

Reply

Sarah October 23, 2008 at 7:54 am

That DAMNED other shoe. I hope you are able to get some answers, and know that you are FAR from alone in the preemies with hearing loss arena – as you know there are any number of things that can cause it. Here’s hoping that it is fluid, but if it’s not you guys will handle it with grace and no matter what, she’s a beautiful, charmingly plump and smart, alien-clad little girl.

Reply

Elise October 23, 2008 at 7:58 am

I’m so sorry. This really does suck and you do not have to be brave and make the best of this right now, you just don’t. Sending good thoughts and wishes your way.

Reply

Mar October 23, 2008 at 8:09 am

I’m so sorry this beautiful baby girl is facing another hurdle – and you as well. I know you’ll come through it with all the grace required but I’m sorry for the fact of it and for how scary that appointment must have been. Best wishes for your family. This is tough work but oh is it good work.

Reply

another karen October 23, 2008 at 8:23 am

i had wanted to comment on your recent “mccain posts” posts and tell you what an amazing writer, what an amazing person, i think you are. but it seemed like everyone else in the world was doing a fine job of that, so i just stayed quiet, lurking as usual.

but i can’t let this post pass without telling you what an amazing person i think you are. what an amazing person i think simone is. (and scott seems pretty damn cool from the small tidbit he’s shown of himself as well.)

everyone is right: simone will be just fine. but i’ll go even one better: simone IS just fine, just as she is, however that turns out to be. she has amazing parents, and she herself has already shown us her amazing courage and strength.

i am so sorry you all have yet another hurdle to face, but i am once again awed by the courage with which you face it head on.

thinking of you,
(another) karen

Reply

Ellen October 23, 2008 at 8:23 am

I’m so sorry, Alexa.

Reply

Anne Glamore October 23, 2008 at 8:25 am

Leave it to you to make me HOWL with your silver lining!

So sorry to hear of your latest battle. Am praying that the days between now and 11-5 will be supernaturally short for you, because knowing something, anything, is better than the wondering and imagining.

Best to your family and kisses to the precious Simone. She hears, but in her own way.

Reply

Lisa V October 23, 2008 at 8:27 am

My best friend’s daughter went from fulling hearing to mostly deaf around 6 from nerve deafness. It was a shock that someone could be hearing and then lose it.

I am sorry you are facing this with the lovely Simone. I’m hoping for the best, and that no matter how it works out you are all given some peace and grace.

But really, this sucks that you have yet one more thing. I thought you had totally filled your “it sucks” allocation for this year.

Reply

Jen October 23, 2008 at 8:30 am

You don’t have to have hearing to “hear”. I think her name is still appropriate and I luh-hove the pajamas.
You’re right. Nothing you can do until Nov 5. And Simone is a happy baby. You’re doing exactly what you should!

Reply

Momsy October 23, 2008 at 8:32 am

Thinking of you all.

Reply

Laura October 23, 2008 at 8:38 am

Coming out of habitual lurkdom to tell you that you are a perfectly excellent and observant mother. So it didn’t occur to you that your perfect baby girl was anything but. Horrors! (I hasten to add that I’m not saying that she is no longer perfect.)

I would imagine that there are lots of scientifically or objectively observable characteristics about my own baby daughter that her father and I do not register because we know her better than anyone in the world. We see an absolute ton of things about her that no one else does, and as a consequence we probably filter out some of the more superficial things that others who don’t know her well might notice more quickly. I bet the same is true of you, Scott and Simone. Add in the fact that you have been seeing family, and friends, and doctors galore for months and none of them noticed that she might not be able to hear either. It took a specialized expert to know the right questions to ask and the right signs to look for.

All of the parents here understand your agony and guilt, but, if I may inject some objectivity, you and Scott are the heroes here because you advocated for her and brought her to the experts to ensure that she received the best care.

Reply

KTBee October 23, 2008 at 8:39 am

I agree with Lorraine #30 – You were driven to name Simone, Simone, for a very specific reason. A reason you may not be aware of yet, but will profoundly reveal itself to you somewhere down the road. I am confident of that. Even the setbacks encourage personal growth and development that you never expect and never thought possible. I am sorry that you guys have to experience another setback, but I can’t wait to see the good that comes out of it.

Reply

bellevelma October 23, 2008 at 8:41 am

I don’t mean to make light of the situation, but I do agree that being able to swear in front of your child without having them go “Awwwwwwwww! You said a bad word! I’m telling Dad!” is a good thing.

Anyway, my thoughts are with you in this difficult time as I know waiting for answers is the hardest part.

Reply

birdie23 October 23, 2008 at 8:45 am

wow I’m so sorry, I just started reading you from your note in Dooce. Simone is a cutie so hang in there. Don’t feel guilty.

Reply

marcoda October 23, 2008 at 8:46 am

Not fair. It’s just not. If any family can deal with this and come out stronger and better at the end, it’s yours.

Reply

moo October 23, 2008 at 8:51 am

my son apparently has no trouble hearing, and yet he doesn’t talk. I get the snowflakes yadda yadda ALL THE TIME, but it really doesn’t make it any easier, does it?

Learn ASL now. Start with the signing time videos, for your own sake. Our local library has them.

You can do this.

Reply

Monica October 23, 2008 at 8:52 am

I’ve learned in the past 22 months there are actually quite a few advantages to having a deaf baby! Who knew with “normal” kids you have to be quiet around the house after 7:30?

Good luck to you guys. There are lots of us hearing mommies with deaf kiddos on the internet ready to jump in with unsolicited advice! :)

Reply

Bumbling October 23, 2008 at 8:54 am

She may not be able to hear your loving words with her beatiful little seashell ears, but she certainly “hears” you with her heart. God Bless Simone, who has overcome so much. I think the new difinition of “Simone” should Be “She Who ‘Hears’ With Her Heart”.
Stay strong Alexa, you are doing a fabulous job.

Reply

snickollet October 23, 2008 at 8:56 am

Sorry you have another hurdle to jump. You’ve already had enough. Really, there should be a limit.

Simone is beautiful and perfect. I’m hoping for the best for her on November 5.

Reply

Marge October 23, 2008 at 8:57 am

My heart goes out to you.

Reply

Mandee October 23, 2008 at 9:05 am

I’m so sorry you have something new to worry about, but I’m holding out hope for the best case scenario.

Reply

kim October 23, 2008 at 9:06 am

Oh honey. While I know that there are worse things – you’ve clearly had to deal with too much. It’s totally normal to feel the way you feel right now. She’s beautiful and perfect, and no matter what, always will be.

Much love and light and prayers on November 5th for the best possible result.

Reply

cindy w October 23, 2008 at 9:10 am

I’m so sorry about this, but it sounds like you’re handling it unbelievably well.

I have to echo the person who mentioned Signing Time. My toddler has no hearing problems but we use the DVD’s because the signs help us to understand her. (For example, daddy and doggy sound exactly alike, but if she signs it, we can understand what she’s talking about.) Rachel Coleman, the woman who hosts the DVD’s, has a daughter who was diagnosed as deaf when she was a year old.

http://www.signingtime.com/

There’s even a series of DVD’s just for babies. Seriously, I can’t recommend them enough. Even if Simone only has temporary hearing loss (fingers & toes crossed), learning some signs might help make up for any speech delays that she might encounter down the road.

Keeping you & your family in my thoughts.

Reply

Kristina October 23, 2008 at 9:12 am

Aw man, that blows. I’m so sorry for both you and Scott.

But Simone is brilliant, and she’s fortunate to have two parents who are equipped to help her overcome any new obstacle. I bet she’ll be fluent in baby sign before November 5. And I hope, along with you and everyone else here, that it’s just a hobby thereafter.

Reply

NICU Mom October 23, 2008 at 9:13 am

I think you need time to be sad about this, so I won’t hit you with any news right now. Simone is still the beautiful and delightful baby you had two days ago, but you need time to adjust to this news. When you’re ready, and if the situation requires it, I can put you in touch with a woman who has a deaf child with cochlear implants who is mainstreamed in school and utterly “normal” (whatever that word means).

Reply

shannon October 23, 2008 at 9:14 am

silver lining #2: at least Simone’s missing the shrill screaming that passes for political campaign discourse. and in that light, the timing of the appointment couldn’t be better…wishing you, Scott, and Simone all the best.

Reply

Erin October 23, 2008 at 9:25 am

Alexa,
I will be thinking of you and Simone in November. For what it is worth (which is probably not alot, because I have learned from experience that the stories of others are just that, but I can’t resist) my son is an ex-25 weeker. First ABR showed severe hearing loss, went to ENT, questionable fluid, but decided to do tubes, found out no fluid but a weird pressure equalization problem that cause the ear drum to be sucked in against the inner ear bones. One the tubes equalized pressure and ear drum healed, hearing was restored.

As many said before, hope something similar is the case for Simone, but if not, I know you’ll do right by her and she will be a very happy little girl.

Reply

Mrs. Moose October 23, 2008 at 9:27 am

I don’t know whether you’re ready to hear the encouraging side of deafness – okay, maybe that’s an odd way of putting it? Anyway, skip this and come back later if you don’t want to hear it yet.

My husband and I took ASL as our language credit in college. Honestly, I took it because it was easier than others, but I learned so much and really got hooked on it. There is a whole deaf culture out there – colleges and schools, neighborhoods, etc. – and some pretty amazing opportunities and really great stuff out there for her. Also, learning ASL would potentially allow her to speak earlier – almost all children have the mental capability to communicate much earlier than their vocal chords so… that’s kind of a plus – less fussing, more communication, etc.

You are in my thoughts and prayers, as is Simone.

Reply

christina October 23, 2008 at 9:36 am

I am so sorry that you are being thrown yet another curveball. Please don’t think that you should not let yourself be fully upset about this because “other people have it much worse” because that is total crap. YOU have had it much worse and you have gotten through it, you and Simone, and you will get through this too. I am hoping for the best case scenario but know that whatever the outcome is, you guys are going to be OK.

Reply

electriclady October 23, 2008 at 9:39 am

I’m so sorry, honey. What a sock in the gut. Hoping for the best.

On the positive side, that is one super munchable baby you’ve got there. Adorable!

Reply

Kristin October 23, 2008 at 10:14 am

Just adding to the supportive chorus of “sorrys” and “I’m thinking of yous”. We’ll keep hoping for the best outcome next month, and while I didn’t read all of the comments, Shannon’s comment at #84 will help with the “you have to laughs…”

Reply

ccr in MA October 23, 2008 at 10:16 am

I’m so sorry for the scary stuff coming again. We’ll all keep our fingers crossed.

Reply

Miss Grace October 23, 2008 at 10:26 am

I’m going to keep clear of the inspirational love stories, because that wouldn’t allow you to properly wallow.

I will say this: I very much hope for the best case scenario.
If it turns out, however, that she can’t hear, I know she has wonderful parents who will still make her life rich with communication and love.

Reply

Glynda the Good October 23, 2008 at 10:28 am

She’s still one GORGEOUS baby. And @ #40, Stacey that is so great to hear that the cochlear implant has been such a success.
Wallow away for a few hours my dear Alexa, and then know that you are a great mom and Simone is beautiful, and that the hearing will be made better.
Hugs to you.

Reply

Sarah October 23, 2008 at 10:28 am

My heart is breaking for you, Alexa. Hoping for the best for you and Simone. She clearly is a lovely baby who is developing just wonderfully is so so many ways. My son is 7 months (not born premature, late in fact) and I’m not sure he could navigate that chair the way Simone is in in this new photo.

Many commenters have posted very useful information here and while the worst case scenario here certainly is heart wrenching, it does sound like Simone will have many many options for this new potential hurdle.

You know you do have to laugh. I have recently been diagnosed with Meniere’s disease, which causes severe vertigo, ringing in the ears, and some hearing loss from damage. I’m hoping they are wrong yet aware they may not be….

So I sit writing you about this issue with my ears plugged and wondering what will become of my hearing, too. I am cheering your family on and knowing that you will always do the best for Simone.

-Sarah

Reply

Adam October 23, 2008 at 10:32 am

I’m so sorry about this shock for you. My parents still tell me the worst day of their lives was when they found out I was deaf.

But never fear…there are thousands of deaf people out there who have made it with the support of loving parents and I see the same thing here. I’m training at UCSD’s ASL/English bilingual program for deaf children and there are so many people out there who will care about Simone.

Simone is not only deaf, she also just became bilingual, and so did the rest of her family! It’s a wonderful skill to have, knowing two languages (ASL and English). Best of luck on your family’s linguistic and cultural journey…just one piece of advice. Read, read, read, read to her in ASL! Reading aloud often and reading to oneself often are the best predictor of academic success.

Reply

Lindsey October 23, 2008 at 10:34 am

Whether Simone ends up hearing or not, her name will always be perfect. Even if, worst case, she is profoundly deaf, her heightened visual perception and the finely tuned observational abilities she will develop will be more sophisticated–albeit metaphorical–”hearing” than most of our plain ol’ listening.

Reply

mslieder October 23, 2008 at 10:36 am

What everyone else said…

It makes me angry at the universe for not giving you one tiny break.

I’m one who laughs (or jokes) when in the depths of despair so the only thing I can offer aside from what everyone else has said is: make sure you conjugate your obscenities correctly.

Reply

Becky October 23, 2008 at 10:45 am

Reminds me of how I felt when my eldest was diagnosed with Autism.

And I think her name is lovely.

Hang in there, Alexa. November 5th is closer than you think.

Reply

Adyn October 23, 2008 at 10:46 am

I have just recently found your blog, and my heart ached for you after reading this.
I found an alternate meaning for Simone(Parents.com)- and it is Hebrew for “God is Listening”
Just wanted you to know that maybe her name is perfect after all- just like she is. I have you in my thoughts, and know that with a Mom like you, she is already steps ahead in life.

Reply

Previous post:

Next post: